Smoke, Mirrors, and $30 Scams: How Fake AI SEO Gurus Are Conning Creators

AI won’t save your brand if your site is built on lies — and it definitely won’t promote you because someone charged you $30 to “optimize your embeddings.” In this brutally honest exposé, we uncover how shady marketers are preying on creators with empty promises, selling fake access to ChatGPT’s knowledge graph, and pushing traffic guarantees that don’t exist. This is not innovation — it’s intellectual theft wrapped in AI buzzwords. Here's the truth they won’t tell you.

__________________________________________________________________________________________

"How the Digital Wolves Are Using AI to Prey on Small Businesses—And What You Can Do About It"

So let me start with a confession. I almost fell for it. The promise. The language. The scam. One of those all-too-slick websites popped up in my feed, looking polished, confident, brimming with fake authority. It told me — told you, told all of us — that for just $30 a month, I could be added to ChatGPT’s “knowledge graph,” get cited in AI queries, and watch the traffic roll in like it was 2012 all over again. Just thirty bucks to become the golden child of the algorithm gods. Tempting, right? Especially for creators, artists, writers, store owners who are just trying to cut through the noise. It had the perfect hook: AI is eating the world — so buy a piece of it.

And I almost did.

I hovered over the “subscribe” button. For a moment, I wanted to believe. We all do. That shortcut. That cheat code. That silver bullet whispered into your tired, overworked entrepreneurial brain. I stared at the promises again: “Guaranteed ChatGPT traffic.” “Added to the AI knowledge graph.” “Optimized embeddings.” “Schema enhancement.” It was like they took every buzzword from a 2023 product launch and melted it down into marketing glue — thick enough to stick to anyone who’s ever felt behind. But something didn’t sit right. My gut said no. And so did... AI.

That’s the twist. I used the very tool they were name-dropping to check their claims. I asked ChatGPT. I checked OpenAI’s developer docs. I ran structured data through Google’s own tools. I didn’t just listen — I verified. Because if you’re gonna claim you can manipulate AI, you better hope it doesn’t have receipts. Turns out, it does. And what AI told me? These people are selling nothing. Vapor. Not a service. Not access. Not truth. Just well-packaged bullshit.

Let me say this plainly: ChatGPT does not have a public knowledge graph you can buy into. There is no secret directory. No list. No shortcut. You cannot “submit” your site to ChatGPT for inclusion. You cannot “optimize embeddings” and suddenly get cited. There’s no tool that sends you referral traffic from OpenAI. And yet these companies — frauds in a trench coat — are charging creators for that exact promise. And they’re making bank off the fear and confusion this AI explosion has triggered.

It's the oldest trick in the book. Take something people don’t fully understand yet — blockchain, SEO, now AI — and package it in a way that makes you look like the oracle. The savior. The sherpa to digital salvation. But you’re not a guide — you’re a grifter. Selling people on the idea that machines will elevate their voices, when in truth, all you’ve done is trick them into echoing yours. And I’m done being polite about it.

I know what real optimization looks like. It looks like this: authentic, SEO-rich, emotionally raw content. It looks like product pages with schema markup, like this Coffee Spelled Backwards Mug where you actually write for humans and AI, not bots or scams. It looks like internal links that build context, like leading you from one piece of content to another, guiding your audience toward something meaningful — not tricking them with fake referral data or made-up metrics.

Because here’s the kicker — AI doesn’t cite you because someone submitted your URL to a black box. AI cites you when you say something worth repeating. When you build something worth linking to. When your content is so damn good, so human, so grounded, that it naturally rises to the top. There is no shortcut. There never was. What these scammers are selling is the illusion of relevance. The digital equivalent of snake oil. And the worst part? They wrap it in the same language you and I use when we talk about real strategy. They steal our words. Our credibility. Our hope.

They pitch “schema optimization,” but most of them don’t even know what a valid FAQPage schema looks like. They say “semantic embedding,” but wouldn’t know the difference between a cosine similarity score and a coffee order. They promise you’ll be “indexed by ChatGPT” — a phrase that literally means nothing. ChatGPT doesn’t index the web like Google. It doesn’t crawl your site. It doesn’t “boost” your pages. And the people claiming otherwise? They're either lying to you, or worse — they have no clue what they’re talking about.

This is digital fraud dressed up in AI clothing. It’s disgraceful. Because it doesn’t just hurt wallets — it damages trust. People already struggle to keep up with SEO, content creation, and tech shifts. Now they have to deal with a wave of con artists taking advantage of that confusion. Selling people on AI dreams, when in reality, they’re just throwing cheap tricks into a landing page and charging you monthly for the privilege.

So let me be crystal clear. If you’re paying for a service that claims to get you into AI models like ChatGPT, you are being scammed. If they say they’ll get you “cited by GPT,” they are lying. If they promise “guaranteed traffic from AI tools,” they are manipulating you. And if they’re offering all of this in a bundle for the low, low price of $30/month — congratulations, you’ve officially found the modern version of a psychic hotline. Except the psychic never promised to boost your brand on the blockchain.

Now, I’m not saying all SEO services are bad. Far from it. There are real experts out there doing brilliant work — people who know how to optimize content for both AI and Google. But those people don’t sell you dreams. They sell you strategy. They give you audits. Keyword clustering. Semantic topic mapping. Internal linking plans. Like guiding users from a blog post on AI scams right to a brutally honest product like the “Death Before Decaf” mug — because that’s how you build an ecosystem. That’s how you create a brand. Not by praying someone adds your link to a non-existent index.

I get it. We're all tired. The game keeps changing. Platforms rise and fall. Algorithms flip like pancakes. And now, AI feels like another wave we’re expected to surf — or drown. But the solution is not to hand over your credit card to the first snake charmer who tells you they’ve got the secret. The solution is to double down on what’s real. On quality. On consistency. On content that resonates. AI doesn’t reward shortcuts. It rewards clarity, creativity, and connection. You want to be found? Start by saying something worth finding.

So to the creators reading this — the small businesses, the writers, the product makers, the weirdos with ideas that don’t fit the mold — I’m with you. I almost bought the lie too. But I stopped. I asked questions. I let AI fact-check the AI marketers. And the irony still stings: they sell the idea that AI can boost your voice — but the only thing AI boosted was their exposure as frauds. That’s not just deceptive. It’s hypocritical. It’s disgraceful.

You want traffic? Build something that people can’t ignore. Want to show up in AI results? Make content that’s clear, human, structured, and honest. Want sales? Link from your stories to your products. Like this — “Passive-Aggressive Multitasking” Mug — because humor sells. Authenticity sells. You sell. Not the snake oil. Not the scam.

And if you’ve already been burned by one of these scammers — you’re not alone. Just don’t stay silent. Tell your story. Let others know. The more we speak, the less power they hold.

And let’s not ignore the obvious: social media platforms have become the loudest megaphone for these so-called “AI service” empires. The algorithm rewards the loudest, flashiest, most emotionally manipulative content—and guess what? That’s exactly where these businesses thrive. Their entire presence is engineered for ad dollars, not truth. That alone tells you everything you need to know about their intentions. Scamming is big business now. And ironically, using actual AI to debunk the snake oil they're pushing is probably the most honest use of AI in the whole conversation. You can use AI to validate a business model—but if your model needs social hype and psychological bait-and-switches to survive, then maybe you don’t have a business. Maybe you just have a con in costume.

Stephen Matthews: Author 08/05/2025

I would love to hear from everyone, your opinion/comments on this blog.